Last Updated on November 16, 2026
This post touches on the “philosophical” differences between System and Organization Controls (SOC) 2 and International Organization for Standardization (ISO) 27001. This is the place to start because where these standards are coming from colors all the activity leading up to an attestation, including what is being attested and the overall cost. Speaking of which, we’ll cover cost/time comparison and other specifics below.
SOC 2 Explained
A SOC 2 report leads off with a narrative (called a System Description) about the company and the service/scope being audited, followed by a description of how the service works and a summary of the controls. In the body of the report, a table outlines details about the Trust Services Criteria (TSC) and associated tests on these criteria.
A SOC 2 system description alone can run from 15 to over 100 pages depending on business complexity. The company also must document “control statements” that explain how they go about providing the relevant controls.
Each TSC basically says, “You should do X.” The company thus needs to craft one or more control statements that describe how their control(s) fulfill that criterion. The auditor then expresses an opinion on whether the control actually fulfills the criterion. Controls that are missing or ineffective are called out as exceptions.
ISO 27001 Explained
John Verry, Lead Managing Director at CBIZ Cybersecurity, points out that ISO 27001 “speaks in many respects to similar criteria that are represented by the SOC 2 TSC.” ISO 27001 is also “supported and embellished” by the ISO 27002 and ISO 27003 guidance, which contribute greatly to the standard’s usefulness.
John goes on to say that what fundamentally differentiates ISO 27001 from SOC 2 is the concept of an information security management system (ISMS) and associated governance processes that overarch the security controls described in ISO 27002 or Annex A of ISO 27001.
That view greatly impacts the audit process. The ISO 27001 certification process has two stages. The first stage is all about the ISMS. Only if that passes muster and all nonconformities are addressed is there any testing of operational controls.
According to John, ISO’s view is that “It doesn’t matter if a company is doing change and asset management and authorization or whatever effectively. If the people steering the ship aren’t doing the right sorts of things, all the operational stuff will be unsustainable and ultimately ineffective. ISO says let’s make sure the leadership is in place: a risk management strategy, an approach for monitoring… then let’s talk about operational specifics.”
Strengths and weaknesses
John adds: “I don’t see ISO 27001 as a ‘point-in-time’ audit as most SOC 2 auditors do, because the evidence we look at extends over the course of a year, and we’ve done an internal audit ahead of time.”
Then John cuts to the chase: “SOC 2 is a much more robust audit [of controls] and that’s why they cost more—because it’s a much deeper dive; a test of many rather than a test of one. In ISO 27001 you audit the management system and then sample the controls because we trust in the management system. Because there’s less of an overarching management system baked into the SOC 2 standard, you do a much more significant sampling to get a better sense of whether the controls are operating effectively over an extended period of time.”
Then it’s “true confessions” time. John: “I don’t think the ISO audits are a robust as they should be. That’s where I love SOC 2—if you want to drill in… a SOC 2 attestation tells you more.”
In short, while ISO 27001 and SOC 2 have different strengths and weaknesses, either one represents an unsurpassed attestation of information security effectiveness for organizations that can meet their stringent criteria.
“SOC 2 or ISO 27001?” is Not the Right Question
That’s not the right question to ask. Start by thinking about your business needs and let that analysis guide your decision.
Many companies seek information security attestations for their clients’ peace of mind, or because proof of a robust security posture is contractually required. But many also want to leverage the process for their own operational risk management.
John elaborates: “What do you need to convey externally for assurance purposes? Is it a logo or two on your website and marketing materials? Is it a logo that links to a certification or a report? Are all your clients asking you for an ISO 27001 certification and they don’t mention SOC 2—or vice versa?”
If a stakeholder asks for a SOC 2 report and you hand them an ISO 27001 certificate, or vice versa, that will be acceptable more than 90% of the time.
And as John points out, “People find ways to make the two frameworks more like each other. For example, the SOC 2 level of detail can be a ‘pro’ if your clients are asking for details. Or it can be a ‘con’ if things went wrong in your audit.
“Or with ISO 27001, one of the pros is, ‘It’s just a certificate.’ And one of the cons is, ‘It’s just a certificate.’ Some of our clients that have ISO 27001 certifications create more robust reports by doing something like a Shared Assessments’ Standardized Control Assessment (SCA) as part of their ISMS internal audit, and just handing [stakeholders] the SCA,” John adds.
Either of the two frameworks offers flexibility and extensibility to help meet current or future needs. For example, the ISO 27000 family of standards includes multiple “add-ons” that help address cloud security risk (ISO 27017/27018).
SOC 2 is designed around categories of Trust Services Criteria (TSC). The Security category is the minimum requirement for any SOC 2 report and includes security and governance controls. Beyond that, the scope of a SOC 2 audit can encompass Confidentiality, Processing Integrity, Privacy and/or Availability.
In summary, either SOC 2 or ISO 27001 offers a wealth of attestation options that businesses can leverage downstream of their initial audit process if need be. Focus on what you need for risk management and for conveying assurance, and choose a framework based on pros and cons for your business specifically.
SOC 2 vs. ISO 27001: Dollars and Sense
Which costs more and why and when?
In terms of the audit and certification costs, “ISO 27001 is different [from SOC 2] in that it’s a 3-year certification,” John explains. “You do a Stage 1 audit, then a Stage 2 audit, then you issue a 3-year certification that needs to be maintained and proven it’s maintained by way of 2 surveillance audits. So within a year of the issuance of the certification the organization needs to be subjected to a surveillance audit.”
John then adds: “In a way, you pay more [for SOC 2] but you are getting more assurance. You know the auditor spent a lot more time verifying you’re secure in a SOC 2 versus an ISO audit.”
Bottom line: While the deliverables are different (a certification versus a report) and the level of detail is greater with SOC 2, the total, end-to-end cost of achieving and maintaining an ISO 27001 certification versus obtaining a SOC 2 report is fairly comparable, with SOC 2 costing somewhat more. Likewise, the cost to build out an information security program to prepare an organization for a SOC 2 or ISO 27001 audit is about the same.
SOC 2 & ISO 27001… The ULTIMATE Security Attestation
Is getting both attestations the best choice for your business?
As John put it, “I think we can agree, having both worked with clients that have both ISO 27001 and SOC 2… Because of the elegance of the two systems and the pros and cons of each, when you combine them together—those are the most secure and best environments I’ve seen.
“So if you really want to do things awesome, the combination of the two frameworks is a little bit unbeatable,” John quips. “You can start with ISO 27001 or start with SOC 2… But if you get to a point where you want to hold your own feet to a fire, the combination of the two…”
Some of the top business benefits of holding both SOC 2 and ISO 27001 attestations include:
- Having such a strong security posture could shorten your sales cycle
- Having all that documentation and detail minimizes the time and effort associated with onsite audits and simplifies the process of responding to questionnaires and other due diligence by stakeholders
- By having such a robust security posture, you could well avoid the cost, legal and reputational impacts of a data breach
John then adds: “If you’re thinking about doing ISO 27001 and SOC 2, there’s more [project] risk and it extends the timeline to do them both concurrently. Yet all in all there’s a cost savings.”
ISO 27001 and SOC 2 have more analogs than differences. Like, you need a scope statement in ISO: that’s a shorthand version of a SOC 2 system description. And in ISO there’s a “statement of applicability”, again, a shorthand version of a SOC 2 controls description. The same concepts are in both so doing them at the same time there’s not a lot of rework.
SOC 2 and ISO 27001 Dual Implementation: Does It Make Sense for Your Business?
We have been seeing a lot of interest among clients and prospective clients in working towards SOC 2 attestation and ISO 27001 certification at the same time. This isn’t unexpected given how much the SOC 2 framework parallels ISO 27001.
Is this a good idea for your business, or any business? How does the synergy between the two frameworks translate into financial and time savings? Why achieve both in the first place?
While there is more overlap than ever between them, ISO 27001 and SOC 2 still address different needs and markets:
- ISO 27001, being an international standard, is of interest to organizations with multinational footprints that must address the needs of global client and/or regulatory demands. It has a wider scope than SOC 2 and encompasses more aspects of security.
- SOC 2 has a narrower focus but addresses the areas it covers in more depth. It is well known in the US, especially in the hi-tech industry, but less so elsewhere. A benefit of SOC 2 is the attestation takes the form of a report that is updated annually. This gives someone who knows how to read it a detailed picture of the status of your controls.
Because some clients or prospects are asking for one and some for the other, some businesses need both. (Growing, US-based SaaS providers that are moving into the global market fall into this category, for example.)
What’s the synergy between the two frameworks in terms of cost, time and effort? If you put one framework on top of the other and look at what’s “the same,” it’s a lot. By the same token, doing both means going deeper in some areas to satisfy SOC 2 requirements than ISO 27001 would require. Likewise, you will be covering areas outside of SOC 2 to address ISO 27001 requirements.
It’s hard to quantify exactly, but our experience is the overlap between the two, in terms of time and effort, is about 25-50%. So, if each took 100 hours to do alone, doing both would take 150 to 175 hours instead of 200 hours altogether.
A dual implementation would save you comparatively more in terms of money than in terms of time. Take simple scenarios like flying your security partner onsite for an audit or gap assessment. The same plane ticket and hotel stay can cover both efforts for just a bit more cost (e.g., one more night in the hotel).
Similarly, if you did Phase 1 steps for both frameworks at the same time you could create basically one set of documents that would reflect your whole game plan for both certifications, and then down the road at audit time, your partner could look at both sets of controls all at once. Not only would you save money on services, but also it wouldn’t “feel” like as much work.
If your company is likely to need both attestations to address the demands of multiple interested parties, take a close look at a dual ISO 27001 and SOC 2 implementation/certification. It could well be a smart move.
CBIZ Pivot Point Security has created a program that allows you to achieve dual implementation by fully embracing the economy of scale and enabling you to avoid performing any meeting, deliverable or task twice.
Have questions about ISO 27001 and/or SOC 2 and which is ideal for your organization? Or maybe both? Contact CBIZ Pivot Point Security to talk over your options with an expert.